History Does Not Repeat Itself, But It Rhymes — Origin uncertain.History Does Not Repeat Itself, But It Rhymes – Quote Investigator
A new commenter, Graybeard (MAINTAINING DECORUM: WILL WE PRESERVE OUR TRADITION OF THE PEACEFUL TRANSITION OF PRESIDENTIAL POWER? – Citizen Tom – comment-99878), suggested I read something. I thought worth passing on. First, here are Graybeard’s observations.
The below author has done an incredible job of connecting all the dots. Smith’s book, “The Permanent Coup: How Enemies Foreign and Domestic Targeted the American President,” came out in August 2020. He lists the details of coup as it was happening. Read the overview at
The Thirty Tyrants – Tablet Magazine
The overview gets off to a slow start and is long. However, read the entire article and you will understand the why of the coup. The question remains, how do we regain control of our country?MAINTAINING DECORUM: WILL WE PRESERVE OUR TRADITION OF THE PEACEFUL TRANSITION OF PRESIDENTIAL POWER? – Citizen Tom – comment-99878
Here is how The Thirty Tyrants – Tablet Magazine starts.
In Chapter 5 of The Prince, Niccolo Machiavelli describes three options for how a conquering power might best treat those it has defeated in war. The first is to ruin them; the second is to rule directly; the third is to create “therein a state of the few which might keep it friendly to you.”
The example Machiavelli gives of the last is the friendly government Sparta established in Athens upon defeating it after 27 years of war in 404 BCE. For the upper caste of an Athenian elite already contemptuous of democracy, the city’s defeat in the Peloponnesian War confirmed that Sparta’s system was preferable. It was a high-spirited military aristocracy ruling over a permanent servant class, the helots, who were periodically slaughtered to condition them to accept their subhuman status. Athenian democracy by contrast gave too much power to the low-born. The pro-Sparta oligarchy used their patrons’ victory to undo the rights of citizens, and settle scores with their domestic rivals, exiling and executing them and confiscating their wealth.
The Athenian government disloyal to Athens’ laws and contemptuous of its traditions was known as the Thirty Tyrants, and understanding its role and function helps explain what is happening in America today. (continued)The Thirty Tyrants – Tablet Magazine
Here is how The Thirty Tyrants – Tablet Magazine ends.
American oligarchy that sees its relationship with China as a shield and sword against their own countrymen. Like Athens’ Thirty Tyrants, they are not simply contemptuous of a political system that recognizes the natural rights of all its citizens that are endowed by our creator; they despise in particular the notion that those they rule have the same rights they do. Witness their newfound respect for the idea that speech should only be free for the enlightened few who know how to use it properly. Like Critias and the pro-Sparta faction, the new American oligarchy believes that democracy’s failures are proof of their own exclusive right to power—and they are happy to rule in partnership with a foreign power that will help them destroy their own countrymen.
What does history teach us about this moment? The bad news is that the Thirty Tyrants exiled notable Athenian democrats and confiscated their property while murdering an estimated 5% of the Athenian population. The good news is that their rule lasted less than a year.The Thirty Tyrants – Tablet Magazine
What is 5 percent of our population? That would be 16,500,000 people. Unlike the relatively small number of deaths from Coronavirus (COVID-19), we would notice the disappearance of our family, friends, and neighbors.
To see what is in between the beginning and the end, click on the link, The Thirty Tyrants – Tablet Magazine.
I have often used the Nehemoller quote and as an aside found it interesting and somewhat infuriating to see it used in a commercial— tweaked of course to fit a progressive slant— changing out some of nehmoller’s original groups to fit today’s narrative— I will certainly check out your latest offering!
When I found out Nehemoller fought the Nazis, I had the same reaction. Progressives, Liberal Democrats, or whatever don’t have genuine heroes of their own. They just have the most efficient thieves.
I think you will find that article quite interesting.
He was in the same league with Bonhoeffer but survived