WHEN DOES TAXATION BECOME STEALING?

What Started This Discussion?

When I wrote a post about our POTUS of Platitudes (here), the subject wandered off topic into the realm of government “investments”. Thus, we have this question from a commenter.

So are you stealing when you drive on an interstate? Is it stealing when you fly from one country to another safely? Is it stealing when the fire department or police show up to help you? The internet was created using shared — or in your view ‘stolen’ resources. Are you stealing now, then? (from here)

What is Heather asking? As I see it, she is asking me what I think is the legitimate function of government? However, she may also trying to put me on the spot. Supposedly, if I mean what I say, I must not drive, accept police and fire protection, use the products of government research, and so forth. I may even have to stop blogging. Of course, that would be absurd; my fan club would suffer enormously. Thus, my position must be absurd.

Can We Equate Taxation With Stealing?

Is the notion that we can equate taxation with stealing absurd? No, but it depends upon how we expect government to spend our money. When government taxes merely to redistribute the wealth, that is wrong. If it is wrong for you or I to play Robin Hood, why is it okay for politicians to play Robin Hood? They have more power? They can get away with it?

Let’s consider Heather’s examples.

  • Driving on the interstate. When we drive on the interstate, we drive on a “free” way. That is, our glorious and wise leaders take money from everyone in the country just so they can build roads for their favorite special interests. In theory we all benefit, but don’t those with the right political connections benefit more?
  • Fire protection. Should we pay for tolls for fire protection? Should we depend upon private charity? As a matter of fact, many fire departments do use volunteers, and that is something we must encourage. Nonetheless, we all benefit from fire protection, and we cannot figure out a way to charge for the service that would not involve an involuntary tax. So government financing appears necessary, presenting us a puzzle. If we believe government exists to protect our rights to Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness, what do we do? Let people burn? No. We leave the problem to local governments. We let the laboratories of republican government do their work. We let the lowest level of government that can solve a problem deal with the problem. 
  • Police protection.  Because we do not know a good way to privately administer justice, we do it collectively through government. Justice does not involve stealing or redistributing the wealth. Justice is about preventing that sort of thing — unless we are talking about so-called “social justice”, a perversion of justice contrived to steal or redistribute the wealth.
  • Government research. When the government “created” the Internet, it applied research. That is, government made use of knowledge that had for the most part already been discovered to solve a specific military problem. DARPA, the government agency most credited with creating the Internet, conducted that applied research for military purposes. Why? We pay for military protection to prevent other nations from stealing and redistributing the wealth of our nation.

Therefore, we have a mixed answer. Sometimes we tax to steal and redistribute the wealth, and sometimes we tax to protect each other’s rights from worse abuses.

Should we all stop driving. No, but we should try to fix the unfairness. When we can insist that each road pay for itself with tolls, we should not allow politicians to arbitrarily decide where and how to build roads. If a road cannot pay for itself, we do not need it.

Are fire and police protection equivalent? No. Firemen protect us from an elemental force; policemen seek to enforce justice. Whereas the administration of justice is the fundamental function of government, fire protection is an adjunct function. Nonetheless, each presents similar issues so we handle these functions similarly.

Why Don’t We Fix The Problem? Why Don’t We Limit The Problem Of Government?

Ask almost anyone the following question: Are you a good person? Most people will promptly respond in the affirmative, and many will be insulted that you even dared to ask. Unfortunately, most of us are wrong. We are not good.

Instead of looking at ourselves through God’s eyes, we find it far more consoling to look at ourselves with our own eyes.

Luke 18:9-14 (Today’s New International Version, ©2005)

The Parable of the Pharisee and the Tax Collector

To some who were confident of their own righteousness and looked down on everyone else, Jesus told this parable: “Two men went up to the temple to pray, one a Pharisee and the other a tax collector. The Pharisee stood by himself and prayed: ‘God, I thank you that I am not like other people—robbers, evildoers, adulterers—or even like this tax collector. I fast twice a week and give a tenth of all I get.’

“But the tax collector stood at a distance. He would not even look up to heaven, but beat his breast and said, ‘God, have mercy on me, a sinner.’

“I tell you that this man, rather than the other, went home justified before God. For all those who exalt themselves will be humbled, and those who humble themselves will be exalted.”

When Jesus spoke of the Pharisees, he was not speaking of “them”. He spoke of people of like us, arrogant souls who desperately want to believe themselves to be good. When we are arrogant, we overestimate what we can do, and we seek to force our fellow human beings to serve our purposes. We convince ourselves we know what is best for them. Then we pervert justice by using government to do others an injustice.

4 thoughts on “WHEN DOES TAXATION BECOME STEALING?

  1. I agree. It’s theft whenever Congress is taking money from taxpayers to pay for things the Constitution has not authorized it to do in the first place.

    The comment about driving on the Interstate being equivalent to stealing is just plain silly. If you’re driving a vehicle, you’re paying state and federal gasoline taxes. That’s one tax that actually makes sense, provided all the revenue generated goes to building and maintaining roads and bridges and so on.

    Both as a moral matter and as a practical matter, ALL charity should be private and voluntary. I would say this even if the government were good at providing it, which it manifestly is not. The private sector — families, neighborhoods, communities, churches, private charitable organizations, etc. — do a far better job with far less waste and at far less cost.

    Like

    1. Oops, sorry — that should have been “the private sector DOES a far better job…” (Guess I’m not quite awake yet.)

      Like

  2. Invite your reader to look up “public good”. In a representative democracy we, The People, agree to create and provide for some public goods. A few are enumerated to be the responsibility of the Federal Government in our Constitution. Charity is not one them.

    State governments have plenary powers. They – if their Constitutions allow – may engage charity all they like.

    It is far better – for many reasons – and far more efficient to have communities of common interests provide charity – and government, the more local the better, be the last safety net. It is wise for government to reduce the tax burden so more communities of common interest – like families – have the money to pay for the compassionate care needed.

    Charity from government is usually abused, corrupted, grossly inefficient and bureaucratic. It is a sad state of being for the people who have to seek their compassion from cold comfort of government.

    Like

Comments are closed.

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑

cookiecrumbstoliveby

Life through the eyes of "cookie"

Rudy u Martinka

What the world needs now in addition to love is wisdom. We are the masters of our own disasters.

Theo-Logis

Supplying the Light of Love

Level_Head

Welcome to Conservative commentary and Christian prayers from Gainesville, Virginia. That's OUTSIDE the Beltway.

The Recovering Legalist

Living a Life of Grace

Write Side of the Road

writing my way through motherhood

Freedom Through Empowerment

Taking ownership of your life brings power to make needed changes. True freedom begins with reliance on God to guide this process and provide what you need.

The Lions Den

"Blending the colorful issues of life with the unapologetic truth of scripture, while adding some gracious ferocity.”

In My Father's House

"...that where I am you may be also." Jn.14:3

Allallt in discussion

Debate and discussion: Reasonable, rational and fair

PUMABydesign001's Blog

“I hope we once again have reminded people that man is not free unless government is limited. There’s a clear cause and effect here that is as neat and predictable as a law of physics: as government expands, liberty contracts.” Ronald Reagan.

TLP

Finding Clear and Simple Faith

Amatopia

Author Alexander Hellene - Sci-Fi - Urban Fantasy - Fantasy - Culture - Art - Entertainment - Music - Fun

John Branyan

something funny is occurring

Because The Bible Wasn't Written In English

Welcome to Conservative commentary and Christian prayers from Gainesville, Virginia. That's OUTSIDE the Beltway.

Fr. Pietraszko's Corner

Discovering Truth and Love

Victory Girls Blog

Welcome to Conservative commentary and Christian prayers from Gainesville, Virginia. That's OUTSIDE the Beltway.

Through Ink & Image

...Pursuing a God Inspired Life

D. Patrick Collins

liberating christian thought

Healthy Mind Ministry

Sharing the Gospel message of hope, strength, love, and peace through Jesus Christ to those who are hurting in their soul or spirit. This is the mission of Healthy Mind Ministry

Conservative Government

Welcome to Conservative commentary and Christian prayers from Gainesville, Virginia. That's OUTSIDE the Beltway.

The Night Wind

Welcome to Conservative commentary and Christian prayers from Gainesville, Virginia. That's OUTSIDE the Beltway.

In Saner Thought

"It is the duty of every man, as far as his ability extends, to detect and expose delusion and error"..Thomas Paine

SGM

Faithful servants never retire. You can retire from your career, but you will never retire from serving God. – Rick Warren

Communio

"Fear Not, Only Believe." Mk. 5:36

All Along the Watchtower

A new commandment I give unto you, That ye love one another; as I have loved you ... John 13:34

The Bull Elephant

Conservative and libertarian news, analysis, and entertainment

Always On Watch: Semper Vigilans

Welcome to Conservative commentary and Christian prayers from Gainesville, Virginia. That's OUTSIDE the Beltway.

The Family Foundation Blog - The Family Foundation

Welcome to Conservative commentary and Christian prayers from Gainesville, Virginia. That's OUTSIDE the Beltway.

Dr. Luis C. Almeida

College Professor

praythroughhistory

Heal the past. Free the present. Bless the future.

Dr. Lloyd Stebbins

Deliberate Joy

Lillie-Put

The place where you can find out what Lillie thinks

He Hath Said

is the source of all wisdom, and the fountain of all comfort; let it dwell in you richly, as a well of living water, springing up unto everlasting life

quotes and notes and opinions

from a Biblical perspective

partneringwitheagles

WHENEVER ANY FORM OF GOVERNMENT BECOMES DESTRUCTIVE OF THESE ENDS (LIFE,LIBERTY,AND THE PURSUIT OF HAPPINESS) IT IS THE RIGHT OF THE PEOPLE TO ALTER OR ABOLISH IT, AND TO INSTITUTE A NEW GOVERNMENT...

nebraskaenergyobserver

The view from the Anglosphere

bluebird of bitterness

The opinions expressed are those of the author. You go get your own opinions.

Pacific Paratrooper

This WordPress.com site is Pacific War era information

Running The Race

Hebrews 12:1

THE RIVER WALK

Daily Thoughts and Meditations as we journey together with our Lord.

atimetoshare.me

My Walk, His Way - daily inspiration

Truth in Palmyra

By Wally Fry

Kingdom Pastor

Living Freely In God's Kingdom

%d bloggers like this: